Tears of repentance flow from an awareness of some sort of “distance” or “disconnect”from God (and others — and even within ourselves), and there is a longing to return. There is no actual distance, of course, between us and God, which would be impossible, but we still do distance ourselves in our thoughts and attitudes.
St. Paul said, “Once you were alienated from God and were enemies in your minds because of your evil behavior” (Colossians 1:21). Yet, even while we were hateful toward God, “we were reconciled to him through the death of his Son — how much more, having been reconciled, shall we be saved through his life!” (Romans 5:10). Even so, we may still often turn away from God, curving inwardly upon ourselves.
There are things that are alien to our nature and not at all what we were created for. We are beset by many things the Fathers called “passions” — disordered movements of the soul that distort human nature and separate us from God in our thoughts. They arise when the soul’s natural powers are misdirected:
What, then, is evil? Clearly it is the passion that enters into the conceptual images in accordance with nature by the intellect; and this need not happen if the intellect keeps watch. Passion is an impulse of the soul contrary to nature, as in the case of mindless love or mindless hatred for someone of for some sensible thing. In the case of love, it may be for needless food, or for a woman, or for money, or for transient glory, or for other sensible objects or on their account. In the case of hatred, it may be for any of the things mentioned, or for someone on account of these things. Again, vice is the wrong use of our conceptual images of things, which leads us to misuse the things themselves. (St. Maximus the Confessor, Four Hundred Texts on Love, 2:15-17)
The powers of the soul were given to us by God for doing good, but when we misuse them, we create the passions. The passions were not planted in us by God, but we ourselves bring them about through our negligence. Yet, the Fathers did not teach that passions must be annihilated — but they must be transfigured.
So we are given the gift of repentance. Repentance is not merely sorrow over wrongdoing but it is a cleansing, a purging of the distortions that have clung to us. When we weep with godly sorrow, it is not because we are being diminished. Quite the opposite, it is because we are being restored. Something is being discerned in us, uprooted in us.
Tears of repentance are not the product of human effort. St. John Climacus, in The Ladder of Divine Ascent, speaks of tears as a second baptism, a gift from God to the humble. Do not force them, or try to work them up — that will do you no good — but do not try to hold them back, either. Let them simply come, for they are healing. When we weep in repentance, the heart is being softened, and the passions are being loosed. The tears we shed mark the nearness of our freedom.
The man who sighs over his soul for but one hour is greater than he who raises the dead by his prayer while dwelling amid many men. The man who is deemed worthy to see himself is greater than he who is deemed worthy to see the angels, for the latter has communion through his bodily eyes, but the former through the eyes of his soul. (St. Isaac the Syrian, Ascetical Homilies)
The end of the Christian life not a cold detachment, but a love that is free, pure, and fully rooted in God. When the soul has brought the passions to their proper us, it is illumined by divine love and becomes like God in all things, with a heart of compassion.
And what is a merciful heart? It is a heart burning with compassion for the whole of creation, for humans, for birds, for animals, and even for demons and all creatures. From the memory and contemplation of them, his eyes flow with tears. Due to great patience, his heart becomes small, and he cannot bear to hear or see any harm of even the slightest sorrow happening in creation. And because of this, he offers prayers with tears at all times. (St. Isaac the Syrian, Ascetical Homilies)
Tears of repentance mean that things are
being uprooted in you that do not belong.
Let them flow freely, for they are
a gift from God, and your
deliverance is at hand.